• Banner 1
  • Banner 2
  • Banner 3

Italian Affair Pizza: Discover the Best Pizza in Sherman, TX

At Italian Affair Pizza, we celebrate the essence of authentic Italian cuisine with a warm, welcoming approach. Established in Sherman, TX, our pizzeria is known for its generous, New York-style slices and a menu that prioritizes quality and flavor. While we may lean more towards takeout, our devoted community appreciates the friendly service and the passion behind each dish. Customers rave about our pizzas and meatballs, creating a loyal following for both casual dining and catering needs. We invite you to immerse yourself in our casual atmosphere—perfect for gatherings and family outings—while savoring food that feels like a slice of Italy.

Italian Affair Pizza at a glance

  • Address 104 N Woods St Sherman, TX 75090
  • Phone (903) 893-2171
  • Restaurant type Pizza restaurant , Italian restaurant , Restaurant .
  • Popular for Popular for lunch , Popular for dinner , Good for solo dining .

Photos & Gallery

Italian Affair Pizza: Reviews & Ratings

Elizabeth Lamb
5

We travel a lot, and this is THE BEST pizza we've ever found! The crust is perfect, sauce tasty and they are not stingy with the cheese. We've never gotten just a slice though-always order our own and take the rest home. There isn't much ambiance to the place, but the pizza is wonderful and staff is kind. We'll miss this place!

Eric Harp
5

BEST PIZZA IN THE WHOLE ENTIRE WORLD HANDS DOWN!!!!!!!!!!!!!! This place is awesome. It has been awesome since it was in the Midway Mall. The staff is great. The pizza is to die for. I HIGHLY recommend checking this place out if you are in town. Absolutely amazing food and the price is awesome. Thank you guys.

Erica
5

The pizza was amazing**, and the spaghetti was decent. The service was friendly but minimal—since you have to grab your own drinks, bus your table, and pick up your food at the counter, it’s very casual. While slightly pricey, the portions are generous, so you get good value. Overall, it’s a solid spot for tasty food in a laid-back atmosphere.

Jason Baldridge
4

I’ve been eating this pizza since I was a teenager. I went to Midway Mall. We ordered slices of this pizza. It moved to Woods street. It’s local staple. It’s a thinner crust, but it’s magic. It’s not crunchy crackers and cheese. It’s crisp, and a tad doughy. I like it. If you want pizza that’s not a chain, visit these folks. It’s priced well.

Nate the great.
5

This Sherman, Texas staple for the best pizza , calzones , strambolis and much more has been in town since I was a teenager at Midway Mall where many of grew up going to the arcade to test our video game skills challenging others to Mortal Kombat followed by a victory slice from The Indian affair and 25 years later in its new location near downtown. Thanks for the memories.

Boogy Toogy
5

Only place in Sherman TX that I've found that serves a NY style pizza. The dough is great and prices are reasonable. The only issue i can say is that by the slice the pepperoni was not cooked enough to my preference. I'm definitely going to order a whole pie next time and I'll bet it will be spot on. I'll post again for that experience. Okay ordered a full pie and toppings were cooked to my liking. Also found out you can request how you'd like it cooked. The only negative I've have to say is their hours of operation. Gotta get that pizza craving taken care of.

Chris Ogborn
5

Italian affair best known as Italian AF is my favorite family own pizzeria. Been going to this place since I was a kid when it was in the midway mall. Would get this over any big corp pizza place

David Waldrop
5

This is our families go to pizza spot! We live in whitesboro and drive here to get pizza cause there is nothing like this around us! New York Style pizza and would highly recommend!

Location

  • Italian Affair Pizza
    Italian Affair Pizza
    104 N Woods St Sherman, TX 75090 Hotline: (903) 893-2171

Welcome to Italian Affair Pizza, a charming pizzeria located at 104 N Woods St, Sherman, TX. Known for its authentic Italian flavors and a casual atmosphere, this eatery has positioned itself as a top choice for pizza enthusiasts in the area. With convenient options for takeout and delivery, it caters perfectly to busy families and pizza lovers alike.

Upon entering Italian Affair Pizza, you might find the space a bit modest, echoing the laid-back vibe typical of neighborhood pizzerias. The restaurant itself may not boast extravagant décor, but the warmth of the owner and staff is evident, allowing for a welcoming dining experience. As noted in numerous customer reviews, the personable service significantly enhances the overall enjoyment of the meal.

Why Choose Italian Affair Pizza?

  • Generous Portions: As one satisfied customer mentioned, their large pizzas are comparable to extra-large sizes found elsewhere, making them a great value. For just $20, you can indulge in a large pizza with two toppings, ensuring that your hunger is thoroughly satisfied.
  • Flavorful Offerings: While the pasta may not steal the spotlight, the meatballs receive honorable mentions for their deliciousness. However, the star attraction remains the pizza. Many patrons describe it as reminiscent of New York slices, with a crust that is both crispy and chewy.
  • Community-Focused: A testament to its local roots, Italian Affair Pizza has been serving the Sherman community since its early days. Frequent customers appreciate the commitment to quality and service from the owner, who is often seen actively engaging with patrons.
  • Family-Friendly Dining: Suitable for groups and families, the restaurant offers private lot parking and outdoor seating. It provides a relaxed environment ideal for enjoying a meal together, whether you're dining in or taking out.

With good vibes and delicious food, Italian Affair Pizza creates a little slice of Italy right here in Sherman. If you’re seeking a casual spot for lunch or a family dinner, this pizzeria undoubtedly should be on your radar. With the availability of Wi-Fi, you can also catch the game on their TV while you savor every bite of your pizza.

Overall, if you’re in Sherman's 75090 area and craving hearty pizza packed with flavor, stop by Italian Affair Pizza. You might just agree with the many customers who have declared it the best pizza in town!

Business Information

  • Accessibility
    • Has wheelchair-accessible car park
    • Has wheelchair-accessible entrance
    • Has wheelchair-accessible seating
    • Has wheelchair-accessible toilet
  • Service options
    • Offers takeaway
    • Serves dine-in
    • Delivery
  • Payments
    • Accepts credit cards
    • Accepts debit cards
    • Accepts NFC mobile payments
    • Credit cards